Stop calling product recommendations adviceBY JIM STACKPOOL | THURSDAY, 3 SEP 2020 12:01PM Would you regard a product recommendation from a Toyota dealer or Apple store as advice? Do you think bias makes a recommendation less valuable? Do you think it matters? Consider ... Upgrade your subscription to access this article
Join the growing community of financial advisers
with unlimited access to our latest news, research and analysis of the industry.
Become a premium subscriber today. |
Latest News
Federal Court lifts Merhi's travel ban
Former financial adviser Ferras Merhi is now free to travel as the Federal Court lifted travel restraint orders imposed one year ago.
Nominations open for the 2026 Power50
Nominations for the 2026 Financial Standard Power50 are now open as we recognise the country's most influential advisers who continue to raise the standards for the profession and provide outstanding service to clients and the wider community.
Advice veteran's exit creates $1bn Tassie wealth group
Mancell Financial Group (MFG) founder Peter Mancell has retired as a financial adviser after 46 years, selling the business he built to pave the way for a $1 billion wealth management firm in Tasmania.
Netwealth expands Morgan Stanley mandate
Amid expanding its stockbroking and private wealth capabilities, Netwealth has been picked by Morgan Stanley to provide a platform solution to its Australian wealth business.
Further Reading
Cover Story
Advice with soul
SACHA BURCHGART
FOUNDER AND FINANCIAL PLANNING SPECIALIST
BURCHEART
FOUNDER AND FINANCIAL PLANNING SPECIALIST
BURCHEART
Though she initially tried, Sacha Burchgart couldn't escape the call of a career in financial advice; it just took staring down her own mortality to see what's possible when you do things differently. Jamie Williamson writes.
Expert Feed
Is software dead?
ECP Asset Management's Damon Callaghan explains the fate of software companies suffering from the 'SaaSpocalypse' that was triggered by the rise of AI.
A governance dashboard is not a governance framework
Research houses are now offering monitoring tools to the licensees who use their ratings. The tools are useful. They do not discharge the governance obligation ...
Helping clients stay the course in volatile markets
Fidelity International's recent research shows many investors are maintaining a "long-term" perspective despite recent market turmoil.
The global advice gap: why expat clients are harder to serve than they appear
Many Australians are building wealth abroad before ultimately returning home for retirement.
I totally agree with this article and its about time we called this situation out as most clients just want advice on product and they do not want to pay for a Rolls Royce when all they need is a Toyota. This is at the very core of why financial advice is so expensive, because we are expected to identify every possible future need in preparing our advice. All we should be doing is to highlight potential situations that might arise in the future and leave it there.
Agree totally with the sentiments expressed above. The Corps Act 2001 sets out the definition of financial product advice (Sec 766B), but this was "conveniently" shortened to financial advice by ASIC in its plethora of regulatory guides regarding financial services.
Overlay that with the "let's cover every scenario" and our butts at the same time approach by legal teams employed by dealers, and you have the recipe for the train wreck we now have.
So, the regulatory body (ASIC) has to sort out the confusion that it has created. Then it has to communicate that "clearly, precisely and effectively" to all stakeholders.
The Hayne Royal Commission needs to be seen for what it was - the express train coming in the opposite direction contributing to the train wreck.
Please don't run away with the idea that advisers are to blame here. Mostly they are only doing what they are told. What we need is to get back to basics. Financial product advice is exactly that. That's what is regulated. Financial advice is not defined in the Corps Act, and nor should it be. It is part and parcel of the every day job of accountants and financial counsellors, as well as those who provide financial product advice.
Very, very frustrating for those of us at the coal face.
ASIC, Hayne Royal commission and FASEA are the main hindrance to the financial advice area going forward.
A simplified and clear expectation model would solve most of the problems in this industry.
Instead we have a complex and over regulated industry with experienced advisers leaving with few new entrants.
Everytime you get lawyers involved (Hayne Royal commission) you run the risk of an unworkable and un-affordable outcome.