Passive versus active: It needs no debateBY JOHN DYALL | THURSDAY, 10 AUG 2017 9:12AMHave we entered the post-truth world in discussing passive versus active investing? There has been a lot of talk recently about the rise of passive versus active in equities investing. Upgrade your subscription to access this article
Join the growing community of financial advisers
with unlimited access to our latest news, research and analysis of the industry.
Become a premium subscriber today. |
Latest News
IFS binds technology offerings to improve advice quality
|Industry Fund Services has launched a new technology suite, which combines its AdviceGen IQ, Profiler IQ and Monitor IQ features, to help super funds improve advice quality.
Low-value tasks, admin barriers for adviser productivity: HUB24
|HUB24 and CoreData has launched the inaugural Adviser Productivity Index, finding the most productive advisers turn around SOAs within three days.
Insignia chief draws 'hard line' on NCAs giving retirement advice
Insignia Financial chief executive Scott Hartley said he draws a hard line when it come to the new class of advisers (NCAs) giving retirement advice.
Entireti launches consulting program for AFSLs
Entireti has launched a new program to support self-licensed firms to design and execute strategic initiatives, while improving performance and competitiveness.
Further Reading
Cover Story

Advice with soul
SACHA BURCHGART
FOUNDER & MANAGING DIRECTOR
BURCHEART PTY LTD
FOUNDER & MANAGING DIRECTOR
BURCHEART PTY LTD
Though she initially tried, Sacha Burchgart couldn't escape the call of a career in financial advice; it just took staring down her own mortality to see what's possible when you do things differently. Jamie Williamson writes.









Passive investment is perfect for advisers that don't know what they are doing. Our in-house blend of active managers has consistently performed better than the equivalent passive counterparts & for less risk on the same asset allocation.
Employed passive Business Develop Managers struggle to understand this because all of their research compares to the "average" active manager. Well there's enough rubbish investment funds out there that pull the average down. A fairly simple comparison is merely looking at the average returns for well rated funds. The moral of the story is don't be slack in your fund selection. Ensure you are with a well rated fund & for the public ensure you are with an adviser that can explain the differences in funds to you.
John, well balanced of both side's arguments and representations. My main beef with comparisons of the two is that it assumes one can (and does) invest in an entire universe of active managers. This seems absurd to me as we cannot do so. Its result is meaningless for investors making an informed appraisal.
It also infers advisers and researchers have no means of value-adding in sorting out the entire universe...which seems an unlikely assumption (though not proven) as well.
Second it should remove active managers that are 'index huggers' at an active price. Say an R2 score over 80 longer term?
Third, yes weightings should be applied if doing like for like, but even then the flaw of point one renders it all useless anyway.
Its interesting to view the performance of active managers that gain the bulk of inflows only against the index over 3 and 5 year rolling periods - of say international Australian domiciled funds since 2000.